Virgin Media


Press Office



Home / Press Office / Press Release

Press Release


Printer Friendly Version View printer-friendly version
«« Back
11/03/09
Broadband Speedtesters still misleading consumers

Virgin Media research reveals flawed tests and false speed results

Virgin Media today released the results of its latest evaluation of web-based speedtests which show that consumers are still being misled by inaccurate results and reports based on unsubstantiated data. Whilst the latest findings show an improvement in speedtest performance, there are still many speedtest and comparison sites which are unable to provide accurate results for regular speeds such as 10Mb, and are a long way from being able to check faster speeds of 20Mb and 50Mb.

Virgin Media’s comprehensive research highlights that millions of consumers, from all ISPs, have been misled for long periods of time due to ‘dirty data’ published by some of the comparison sites or via erroneous speedtest results presented to consumers. When Virgin Media started this research, only two online speedtest sites, thinkbroadband.com and speedtest.net, had the ability to accurately measure all three speeds, 10Mb, 20Mb and 50Mb. As a result of ongoing collaboration, just two more sites; broadband-expert.co.uk and ispreview.co.uk, have reached the required standards to be accurate enough to measure up to 50Mb.

Jon James, Director of Broadband at Virgin Media said, “We’re dismayed to find that for years, many speedtest and comparison sites have been misleading the public on ISP performance. Consumers rely on these sites for clear advice and honest results. The fact that many of them cannot accurately measure speeds of 20Mb, and some cannot even accurately measure speeds of 10Mb, demonstrates there is a clear need for more transparency. As ultrafast services such as 50Mb become more mainstream, this issue will need to be addressed quickly.”

Virgin Media began this campaign to ensure web-based speedtesters were able to accurately measure next-generation high-speed broadband services ahead of the launch of its ‘up to 50Mb’ broadband product. The initial results demonstrated that most web-based speedtest sites were unable to accurately measure throughput of this new ultrafast 50Mb service, and customers attempting to test the speed this new service would be getting results that were not a true reflection of their service.

Since the campaign launched last October, Virgin Media has been working with all the major speedtest sites to assist them in improving their testing systems. As a result of this collaborative approach, some of the speedtest sites have been working to improve their speedtest applications and a handful have put in place a warning so that consumers are aware their existing speedtests may be unable to provide accurate results for high speed connections.

However despite this initiative, three months on from the launch of the 50Mb service, the majority are still unable to accurately measure ultrafast services, and still do not make consumers aware of the numerous factors that could affect their results. Worse still, further testing taken place over the last couple of months on speeds such as 10Mb and 20Mb, has revealed startling evidence that many of these sites have been reporting false results on these speeds for years.

“Many of these sites profess to be ‘experts’ and some even generate sales from broadband providers so I am sure that consumers would find it alarming that they are unable to accurately represent speeds accurately. We are pleased, however, that our campaign has kick-started most of these sites into action and we will continue to work with those that are non-compliant to get them to the standard that they need to be,” Jon James added.

Virgin Media has shared its findings with ISPA (Internet Service Providers Association) and Ofcom.

To find out more about Virgin Media’s products and service visit www.virginmedia.com or call 0800 052 2525.

Ends

Media contacts

Asam Ahmad, asam.ahmad@virginmedia.co.uk, 0207 909 2122

Notes to editors

Speedtest Site

10Mb

20Mb

50Mb

Notes

speedtest.net (London)

YES

YES

YES

Has been 50Mb ready since start of campaign, however have made improvements to testing algorithm and plan to introduce Northern server

speedtest.net (Maidenhead)

YES

YES

YES

Hosting/Server change at Maidenhead site coupled with changes to algorithm have improved results.

thinkbroadband.com

YES

YES

YES

Has been 50Mb ready since start of campaign

broadband-expert.co.uk

YES

--

YES

Site was unavailable during 20Mb testing, however use same technology as speedtest.net (by Ookla)

ispreview.co.uk

YES

YES

YES

Now using thinkbroadband’s technology.

numion.com

YES*

YES

YES*

*Inconsistent results on 10Mb and 50Mb

speedchecker.org

YES*

YES

NO

*Unable to measure 50Mb, with inconsistent results during 10Mb tests

broadband.co.uk

YES

NO

NO

Unable to measure over 10Mb accurately. Releasing monthly results using inaccurate data.

broadbandspeedchecker.co.uk

YES

NO

YES*

*Inconsistent results on speeds above 10Mb. Currently working on improvements to test.

broadbandchoices.co.uk

NO

NO

NO

Working on improvements to testing system.

broadbandgenie.co.uk

NO

NO

NO

Working on improvements to testing system.

broadbandwatchdog.co.uk

NO

NO

NO

Working on improvements to testing system.

  • Tests were carried out during December 2008 - January 2009
  • A desktop PC (minimum spec 2GHz+, 512MB RAM) using Windows XP Operating System with RWIN optimised for the tiers of service was used for testing.
  • The PC was directly connected to the Cable Modem to eliminate local/wi-fi networking issues
  • The Virgin Media “Next Generation” platform was used to ensure that there are no contention or capacity issues introduced on the Virgin Media side.
  • A speed test receives a pass mark if it is able to consistently report 90% or over of actual throughput

Virgin Media
With almost 10 million customers, Virgin Media is the UK's first quad-play provider of broadband, TV, phone and mobile.

The company is the largest residential broadband provider in the UK, using a unique fibre optic cable network to deliver next generation ultrafast internet access of up to 50Mb to just over half of all homes. Combined with a high speed ADSL service and mobile broadband products, Virgin Media is able to offer broadband internet access to virtually the entire country.

Virgin Media has the UK’s most advanced TV on demand service and is the only TV platform to carry BBC iPlayer. It is the second largest provider of pay TV, was the first to launch a high definition TV service and offers a high-specification, HD-ready V+ personal video recorder.

The company operates the most popular virtual mobile network in the UK which, when launched, was the world’s first such mobile phone service. It is also one of the largest fixed-line home phone providers in the country.

Virgin Media owns two content businesses – Virgin Media Television (VMtv) and sit-up. VMtv owns eight entertainment channels, including Virgin1, Living, Bravo and Challenge – and is a 50 per cent joint partner with the BBC Worldwide in UKTV which consists of ten channels including Dave, G.O.L.D., Watch and Alibi. sit-up runs retail TV channels bid tv, price-drop tv and speed auction tv.

With operations based entirely in the UK, Virgin Media Inc. is listed on the NASDAQ Stock Market (VMED).

For more information, go to www.virginmedia.com.